Bugmeister QA tasks
Contents
Queries for bugmeister QA
These are some queries for "situations that probably ought not to exist in Bugzilla". These can either be things such as now-unsupported FreeBSD versions, or other things that were never right in the fist place. For comparison, see the list of regular queries.
Bugmeister should check these regularly and reclassify/clean up if necessary.
General metadata problems
Description |
Recent count |
Comments |
18 |
|
|
4 |
|
|
14 |
|
|
6526 |
little hope. |
|
0 |
Issues may be ripe for reassignment / Assignee reset |
|
3373 |
Issues may be ripe for reassignment / Assignee reset |
|
246 (~64 to !=mailing list) |
|
|
PR is still New/Open/In Progress but has been commented on by commit-hook@FreeBSD.org |
350 |
some need either MFC/MFH or just closed; some are just misfiled commit-hook@s; all of the easy ones have been triaged out by MarkLinimon 20250214 |
121 |
might need either MFC/MFH or just closed; triaged by MarkLinimon 20250302 |
|
8 |
|
|
0 |
|
|
Ports & Packages maintainer-approval +, non-obsolete patch, open or in progress, assigned to ports-bugs@ (not yet assigned to a person) |
15 |
not yet refined to exclude bugs such as 246873, where (2021-11-11) maintainer-approval+ is for patches that are obsolete; does not find bugs such as 269081, where (2023-01-21) maintainer-approval+ is for something other than the patch |
… maintainer-approval +, non-obsolete patch, new (not triaged), assigned to ports-bugs@ |
22 |
|
5977 |
still overcounts via mailing lists |
|
3120 |
|
|
1 |
may be set to indicate in-line patch |
|
1 |
|
|
0 |
|
|
0 |
|
Attachment metadata problems
Description |
Recent count |
Comments |
1744 |
|
|
... named diff |
533 |
|
... named patch |
969 |
|
1390 |
|
|
... named shar |
81 |
|
1446 |
|
|
Issues with Attachments of type:patch but filename contains neither diff nor patch |
14 |
sometimes you see "shar" for new-port, but the others might need editing |
356 |
lots of false positives here (logfiles etc.); last triaged 20240930 by MarkLinimon |
|
9 |
often needs attachment Patch flag set, too |
|
0 |
often needs attachment Patch flag set, too |
|
33 |
sometimes you see new ports submitted this way |
Searches By Obsolete Versions
(NB: these searches have meaning in the Base System product only)
![/!\](/moin_static1911/modern/img/alert.png "/!\"){kind=small}
These PRs are not automatically OBE -- they need to be checked.
search description |
Recent count (all) |
Recent count (bin) |
Recent count (conf) |
Recent count (kern) |
Recent count (misc) |
comments |
12 |
|
|||||
11 |
|
|||||
10 |
|
|||||
9 |
|
|||||
8 |
|
|||||
7 |
|
|||||
6 |
|
See also: Unsupported Releases; param.h; HistoricalMajorBranchPoints
Searches By Ambiguous Versions
(NB: these searches have meaning in the Base System product only)
search description |
Recent count |
comments |
1752 |
|
See also: Supported Releases; param.h; HistoricalMajorBranchPoints
Searches By Obsolete MFCs
(NB: these searches have meaning in the Base System product only)
These PRs are not automatically OBE -- they need to be checked.
0 |
support ended 20231231 |
|
0 |
support ended 20210930 |
|
0 |
support ended 20181031 |
|
0 |
support ended 20161231 |
See also: Unsupported Releases; param.h; HistoricalMajorBranchPoints
Searches By Obsolete Code
As time goes by, some code becomes obsolete. PRs for these should be periodically pruned, preferrably with an apology that we did not get to it.
Searches By Code Obsoleted By Later Import
TODO
USB previous to removal of legacy USB stack 20090527
ZFS previous to OpenZFS import 20200825 (triaged by MarkLinimon 20250119)
- etc.
Searches By Code For Removed Features
TODO
- gbde
- mergemaster
ndis was removed 20210125 (triaged by allanj 20250118)
- etc.
See also: ObsoleteFiles.inc in src.
Searches By Obsolete Architectures
As of 20231225, all the ones in Bugzilla seem to have been closed as OBE -- however, not so Phabricator.
Searches By Creation Date
year |
search description |
Recent count |
2024 |
Base System |
|
2023 |
Base System |
|
2022 |
Base System |
|
2021 |
Base System |
|
2020 |
Base System |
|
2019 |
Base System |
|
2018 |
Base System |
|
2017 |
Base System |
|
2016 |
Base System |
|
2015 |
Base System |
|
2014 |
Base System |
|
2013 |
Base System |
|
2012 |
Base System |
|
2011 |
Base System |
|
2010 |
Base System |
|
200x |
Base System |
|
199x |
Base System |
Miscellaneous
See also
PR assignment QA
Bugmeister should check FreeBSD Developer Lists periodically and deassign PRs assigned to committer alumni. There is currently no automated way to view this list. (last triaged 20240925 by MarkLinimon)
(for reference: look up PRs assigned to Bugmeister)
I went through ObsoleteFiles.inc from the most recent entry down to 20201124 before I got tired. -- asomers